The Lost Symbol (Kindle Edition)
A quick note on the ranking: I hold 5-star ratings in reserve for the best of the best. The previous Robert Langdon books I would rate at about 4 stars for being fun reads but nothing that would resemble a literary masterpiece. I enjoyed this book significantly less than the other two, hence the two stars.
‘The Lost Symbol’ is not a bad book. While it would certainly rank it 3rd amongst the three Robert Langdon novels it is still an amusing read. I forgive Brown for his weak writing style and I accept that he writes characters that are fairly two-dimensional with little personality outside of that which pertains explicitly to the story. I accept that this novel was going to have the exact same story structure and characters as the previous two. I accept that the relationships between people will be odd. I accept that most chapters will end with a variation on his cheap cliffhanger “And then Robert couldn’t believe what he saw!” I accept all that. And yet, even with all those concessions, this one just left me flat.
When it comes to the writing style I’m not entirely sure if I should be blaming Brown or his editor (or, potentially, his lack thereof-which I guess would be blaming him). The style, while simple, could easily be smoothed out with an editor who was given some room to work. What hurts his prose is repetition of words and phrases over and over and over and over-often on the same page.
Sure, the story structure is an identical match to the first two with all the same types of characters and twists. But here’s the issue, this time is just doesn’t work like it did before. Here’s why:
1. Robert Langdon is officially a moron: He spends more time being lectured to and making wrong guesses than he does solving anything. His inner monologue serves to deliver some interesting asides, but nothing that helps forward the plot. I’m fairly certain he figured out absolutely nothing critical in the last third of the book. He was completely marginalized.
2. The science of Noetics, as used in this book, is a complete throwaway with no bearing on the plot: In A&D the science of matter and anti-matter played a significant role in the overall plot. It’s relation to the Big Bang and religion as well as its overall implementation throughout the story was essential. Here, the Noetics pops up just enough to be annoying once you realize it serves no primary purpose. Also, Noetics is barely a science. Reading this book would make one think it’s far more legitimate than it is. I was fascinated several years ago when I first heard it mentioned. Upon further research one finds that it is more wishful thinking than science and that it has very little actual research and support. Closer looks at studies (the water that has been “loved” is a favorite) show gaping holes, inconsistencies, and a complete lack of scientific method. While it may sound nice it just serves no purpose.
3. The payoff just doesn’t work: Maybe we’re out of major historical secrets to reveal to the world because this one just fizzles out. The build-up of this story often felt like it was stretching. In the previous Robert Langdon novels he finds himself moving between a great many locations surrounded by symbols and puzzles. Here, he spends his time in a handful of buildings, several of which play no role in solving anything but are simply places for him to rest or think. I often found myself turning pages, not to see what happened next, but to see if ANYTHING happened next. The reveals in the first two were very cool. This one gets such hype and then comes the “Really? That’s it. I just read 500 pages to find THAT out? There’s a few hours I’ll never have back.” moment.
I can say, unequivocally, that when the special edition with all the pictures is released I will absolutely not be purchasing it. I just don’t care to ever read this novel again. I learned a few things about history and there were some interesting parts. But overall it was just mediocre, and sometimes that’s worse than being bad.
About the Author
http://amazonviews.blogspot.com/
Kindle 2 hacks, Cool Science Gadgets, What can I do wtih a Lithuim Battery??
|
|
American Weigh Gemini-20 Portable Milligram Scale, 20 by 0.001 G $21.00 Backlit LCD display Built-in weight holder on scale. Capacity 20g / 0.7055oz / 0.6430ozt / 100ct / 12.860dwt/ 308.64 gn Readability 0.001g / 0.0001oz / 0.0001ozt / 0.005ct / 0.001dwt/ 0.02 gn Scale Dimensions 3.0 x 5.0 x 0.75″ Platform Dimensions 0.7″ Diameter (1.3″ with tray) Warranty 10 Year Limited Warranty Power 2 x AAA Batteries (included)… |
|
|
Jim Frankenstein, Rock and Roll Space Priest in: Forgotten Soul Father Jim Frankenstein has been living in Epsilon Eridani for almost five years now and just as he’s beginning to settle in, Roman Giles walks into his life. Roman is a Paranormal Detective who’s just caught a case that requires help from a man of God, and Jim happens to be the only one around.With the help of Kazuko, an ass-kicking android police detective, Jim and Roman set out to ease the trou… |
|
|
Girls to the Front: The True Story of the Riot Grrrl Revolution $12.99 Girls to the Front is the epic, definitive history of Riot Grrrl—the radical feminist uprising that exploded into the public eye in the 1990s and included incendiary punk bands Bikini Kill, Bratmobile, Heavens to Betsy, and Huggy Bear. A dynamic chronicle not just a movement but an era, this is the story of a group of pissed—off girls with no patience for sexism and no intention of keepi… |
|
|
Lexicon Devil: The Fast Times and Short Life of Darby Crash and The Germs $16.95 “Lexicon Devil is, pure and simple, the finest volume on punk to have seen the light of print. (Yes, folks: that includes Please Kill Me.) Great book!”—Richard Meltzer Production has started on the documentary feature based on the book…. |
|
|
Rise Of The Planet of the Apes $3.99 … |
|
|
Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers – Extended Edition $12.99 … |
Tags: books, ebooks, education, free, kindle science books, kindle science fiction, kindle science fiction books, kindle science fiction free, kindle science news, science